Mom’s Secret Stash

  • Mom’s Secret Stash

    Mom’s Secret Stash

  • Cake Batter Rice Crispy Treat

    Cake Batter Rice Crispy Treat

  • Pretzel Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Pretzel Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Brown Butter Rice Crispy Treat

    Brown Butter Rice Crispy Treat

  • Butterscotch Potato Chip Cookies

    Butterscotch Potato Chip Cookies

Buy Now

Gifting just got better.

We invite you to join us in redefining the art of gifting. Elevate your gifting experience with our handcrafted cookies and create moments that truly matter. Choose Cookie Nookie, where heartfelt celebrations begin.

Shop our Treats

  • Nookie in a Jar

    Nookie in a Jar

  • Cookies

    Cookies

  • Rice Krispy Treats

    Rice Crisps Treats

  • Variety Box

    Variety Boxes

  • Treat of the Month

    Treat of the Month

  • Gourmet Chex Mix

    Gourmet Chex Mix

Shop Now

Our Story

My name is Natalie. Our story started in the Caribbean where I was born and raised. My mom is from Barbados, my dad is from Grenada, and my siblings and I were born in Jamaica but grew up mainly on the tiny beautiful island of Dominica. I come from a family of bakers; it runs in my blood. Had my aunt had a bakery, her bread would put us out of business - it’s so good! Since I can remember,…

Customer Reviews

  • Amanda McClellan -March 6, 2021

    Cookies arrived quickly and completely intact. The care in packaging for shipping never disappoints! Plus, the presentation (box, bow, etc.) is superb. Now, for the cookies…ORDER SOME NOW! You will not be disappointed. Fresh, baked with love, and oh, so yummy!!! I love them all!! Seriously, you can’t go wrong.

  • Lizaura German - June 21, 2021

    I can’t believe these were gluten free cookies. They tasted amazing. My husband and son who aren’t gluten free loved them too. So happy I ordered. Thanks for my new addiction.

  • Amanda – July 31, 2024

    THESE RICE KRISPIES I THE GRAB BAG ARE SOOOOO GOOD! Melt in my mouth soft. I assume each rectangle is 1 serving, right?! 😂 I was initially going to share with my boyfriend, but he’s on a work trip, and I don’t think these will last. So so so good!!!! 🤤 I’m so glad I snagged a grab bag! And it arrived so fast too!!!!

  • Abigail P. -February 23, 2021

    I had these sent to my best friend (who is gluten free). Of course they shipped just as Texas was experiencing freezing and power outages…so I was worried because they took longer than normal to arrive. Well let’s just say she texted me saying she had eaten 3 – for breakfast! And then ate more throughout the day! So I guess I shouldn’t have been worried. She loved them!!!!

  • Amy C. – April 25, 2021

    Best gluten free cookies I have ever had!! I have to hide some for my own stash or my son eats them all! Natalie and Wilson are so sweet and adorable and their love is definitely baked in their cookies! ?

  • Andrea C. – June 18, 2021

    This was the 5th time I’ve ordered from Cookie Nookie (2 for my family and 3 as gifts) and every single time these are a huge hit! They are DELICIOUS and always so beautifully packaged. Everyone loves them!

WHAT’S BAKIN’?

Tips, recipes, and inspiration for both your baking adventures and family life.

Featured
How to Make Perfectly Soft and Chewy Snickerdoodle Cookies
How to Make Perfectly Soft and Chewy Snickerdoodle Cookies

Discover the simple joy of baking Snickerdoodle cookies with this quick and easy recipe. With a soft, chewy texture and a sweet cinnamon-sugar coating, these classic cookies are perfect for any occasion. Learn about their origins and get tips on how to freeze the dough for a quick treat anytime. Plus, find out how our Nookie in a Jar makes baking these delicious cookies even easier!

Read More →
How to Make Delicious Cookies in Minutes with Nookie in a Jar
How to Make Delicious Cookies in Minutes with Nookie in a Jar

Craving freshly baked cookies without the hassle? Our Nookie in a Jar makes it easier than ever to whip up a batch of warm, gooey cookies in just minutes. With pre-measured, high-quality ingredients, all you need to do is add a few wet ingredients, mix, and bake! Perfect for busy days or a quick sweet treat, Nookie in a Jar brings the joy of homemade cookies right to your kitchen. Discover how easy baking can be and grab your jar today!

Read More →
The Importance of Getting Your Kids Involved in Baking from a Young Age
The Importance of Getting Your Kids Involved in Baking from a Young Age

Baking with your kids is more than just fun—it’s a valuable way to teach essential life skills, foster creativity, and strengthen family bonds. From developing math and reading skills to encouraging healthy eating habits, involving your little ones in the kitchen can have lasting benefits. Start today with Nookie in a Jar and create delicious memories together!

Read More →